The Gang of Five
The forum will have some maintenance done in the next couple of months. We have also made a decision concerning AI art in the art section.


Please see this post for more details.

GOF Awards 2013 Rules, Voters List, Award Draft

Malte279

  • The Circle
  • The Gang of Five
  • *
    • Posts: 15608
    • View Profile
    • http://www.ineinemlandvorunsererzeit.de.vu
It is that time again. No, not the wheel of morality but the Award voting of 2013 are about to begin.
First of all here are the rules. Thanks to Iris for taking on the task of refreshing the rules and decorate with fancy notes :lol
Everyone please read through the rules and ask if you have any questions about any of them:

Newly written rules:

The voting process will officially open on 9 August and will be started by an opening speech from one of the members of staff of the GOF. You cannot start voting before this opening speech.
Voting for the initial 7 categories will last for 2 weeks and will close at 12 (midnight) on 23 August 2013 (forum standard time)

We understand it is a wall of text, but we would like you to at least read through the rules once before you start voting so that you won't breach any rules.

♪♫♪ OFFICIAL RULES AND REGULATIONS FOR 2013 GANG OF FIVE MEMBERSHIP AWARDS ♪♫♪

1)  All selected GOF members listed are invited to participate in the GOF Awards. These candidates have been granted participation on clearing of the following conditions:
A. Have a post count of at least 100 posts
B. Have been active on the GOF within the past 3 months
C. Have been a member of the GOF for at least 3 months
The list of eligible candidates for this year's awards can be found below! If your name is not on that list, you are not eligible to receive an award in this year's nominations. If you find you fulfil the three criteria listed above and still are not on the list, please contact one of the admins about it. We do our very best, but mistakes are always possible.

- The Appreciated Member Award will also be included but nominations for this award will be conducted AFTER the main 7 categories have been finalised and the awards distributed. DO NOT reveal your nomination for the Appreciated Member Award alongside your votes for the initial 7 categories because it won't be counted.

2)   You are to offer one (1) nomination per category highlighting the nominee's GOF username in underline and/or bold to aid with the tallying process. We strongly advise all participants to vote in every category if possible.
Understandably there may be some areas you are not too sure on if you haven't been involved directly (e.g. the RPG section) or are genuinely unable to select one candidate but we urge you try to offer a nomination if you can.

3)   If you want to be entitled to win an award, you will have to vote for at least 6 out of 8 categories. In case you did not vote in at least 6 categories, you will not receive any awards you are entitled to. The awards will instead go to the member with the second highest amount of votes. If you are not interested in winning an award, but still wish to vote in several categories, you are allowed to do so.

4) If you skip 2 votes in the first 7 categories, you are obliged to vote in the Appreciated Member award in order to win an award yourself.

- The Appreciated Member Award voting will be held after the main 7 categories have been finalised and the awards distributed, since only members who didn't win any of these 7 categories can be voted for the Appreciated Member Award. DO NOT reveal your nomination for the Appreciated Member Award alongside your votes for the initial 7 categories because it won't be counted.

5) All nominations must be accompanied with a few lines or a brief statement as to why you feel your choice deserves the award. It doesn't have to be long, but it should at least help enforce your choice so that it can be counted as valid reasoning. Feel free to express credit to those member you felt were close contenders for an award if you wish. Nominations without explanatory comments will count as a skipped vote, so make sure to include them!

6) If you do not complete all your nominations in one post, please submit the remainder of your nominations in a separate post. Please do not edit/update previous posts, since this will confuse the one keeping record of the votes. We will constantly update your votes and will not go back to check older posts once votes are cast.

7) We discourage voting for yourself in any given category for the awards. if you genuinely feel that there are no other eligible candidates who deserve a specific award then you are permitted to vote for yourself in 1 category only. Voting for yourself more than once will count as skipped votes. In case a tie in number of votes comes up, the candidate who did not vote for themselves automatically wins the award.

8) The candidate who gets most votes for an award will be permitted to add one of the drafts of the award to his or her signature. The candidate with the second most votes can choose one of the drafts of the awards after the winner has chosen his and can call himself the runner up! Runner ups must have at least one third of the votes the winner had and cannot use the same banner as the winner. Runner ups do not have to state that their award is a runner up, they can be just as proud as the actual winners.

9) In case two members get an equal amount of votes and are both entitled to either the award or a runner up award there will be a tiebreaking vote. These will be held after the main voting and before the Appreciated Member award voting. This final tiebreaker will decide who wins the award.

And lastly, we would like to remind you all that the awards are here for fun. Any activity that could be considered ruining the fun will disqualify you from the awards and might even result in a harsher action if necessary. Here is a list of what we find unacceptable:
  • Cheating
  • Bribing
  • Vote fixing
  • Conspiring
  • Any general misconduct of ensuring that one GOF member will be guaranteed an award
  • Claim an award when you're not elected
We want all of you to have as much fun as possible and we can only assure that if you help along yourself.

Thanks for reading. If there are any other questions feel free to post them below :)

- The main categories for this year's Awards are as follows -
~Fanart Award
~Feedback Award
~Friendly Member Award
~Helpful Member Award
~Philosopher Award
~Proactive Award
~Role Play Gamer Award


Malte279

  • The Circle
  • The Gang of Five
  • *
    • Posts: 15608
    • View Profile
    • http://www.ineinemlandvorunsererzeit.de.vu
Once again credit goes to Iris for creating the list of members who may vote and be elected for awards. Members that is who have been around for at least three months (and have been active within the last three months), and posted more than 100 times.
In case you fullfill the criteria but are not on the list, please contact us about it.

 List of eligible members:

2007excalibur2007
Achillobator
action9000
Adder
Allicloud
Almaron
Animeboye
Belmont2500
Blais_13
Blitz
Bongo
brekclub85
buffypii
bushwacked
Campion1
Cancerian Tiger
Caustizer
Chiletrek
Chomper4
Chomper98
Clawandfang
Coyote_A
crazedwriter
Cyberlizard
Daddytops2009
Darkhououmon
Dima02
Dosu2Dinner
Drake
Ducky123
F-14 Ace
f-22 "raptor" ace
Flathead770
FlipperBoidSkua
FreckledOne
Fyn16
Ghostfishe
jansenov
JitteryDragon
Jrd89
Justin1993
kjeldo
Kor
landbeforetimelover
LBTComeback
LBTDiclonius
LBTFan13
LBTLover1
LettuceBacon&Tomato
Littlefoot Fan
Littlefoot Fan 93
Littlefoot1616
Littlefoot3897
Littlefoot90
Loofah
LoyfeCycleProtector
Ludichris1
Malte279
MC CJ'S REVENGE
metadude1234
Mirumoto_Kenjiro
Mr Wonk
Mumbling
MurMur
Myrkin
Nahla
NeptuneNavigator2001
NewOrder
Nick22
Nimrod
Nintendoofah64
oogaboo
Pangaea
PanickyPetrie14
Paradise Bird
Petrie85
Pikkutassu
pokeplayer984
Pterano
Ptyra
RainbowGirl 39
Rat_lady7
Rocky
Serris
Simba King Of Pride Rock
somerandomfangirl
Spartanguy88
StarfallRaptor
Stitch
StrutEggStealer
Tails_155
The Anonymous Person
The Chronicler
The Dark Patriot
The Friendly Sharptooth
The Great Valley Guardian
thebigdeal
trulyfantasticme
Tyrannosaur
Vilstrup
vonboy
WeirdRaptor
Zimba


Malte279

  • The Circle
  • The Gang of Five
  • *
    • Posts: 15608
    • View Profile
    • http://www.ineinemlandvorunsererzeit.de.vu
Here come the drafts for the awards and explanations what they are about (it requires some double posting due to limits of the number of pictures permitted in one post) ;)

Fanart Awards:
The Fanart Award is for the member whose fanart is particularly appreciated by the members of the GOF for their style, content, and / or simply subjective taste. The fanart award is meant for the kinds of art which is made by a single artist, rather than in a group effort, and which is primarily based on the artists own work rather than a new combination of the work of others. This includes drawings, paintings and LBT figures.

Fanart Awards (11 drafts total)














Malte279

  • The Circle
  • The Gang of Five
  • *
    • Posts: 15608
    • View Profile
    • http://www.ineinemlandvorunsererzeit.de.vu
Feedback Awards:
The Feedback Award is meant to give credit to those who give credit to others by responding to their posts of fanart or projects. Getting reactions to fanart and projects may help artitsts to further improve their work and it can also be a strong motivator for the artists to create and to post their work in the first place. Both the kindness (flaming is neither helpful nor permited nor existend in the GOF) and the helpfulness (it is easy to tell somebody that all is perfect, but it is more helping to tell artists if you see room for improvement or be precise on what exactly it is that you like about their work) of feedback as to let the artist know what the author thinks about his or her fanart are to be taken into account.

Feedback Awards (9 drafts total)



















Malte279

  • The Circle
  • The Gang of Five
  • *
    • Posts: 15608
    • View Profile
    • http://www.ineinemlandvorunsererzeit.de.vu
Friendly Member Awards:
The Friendly Member Award is to be issued to the member whom the majority voted for being the most friendly and easygoing in general interaction. It is meant to be a reward to those who contribute to making the GOF a hospitable place through sheer kindness, for those who make people feel welcome around here. Because of the great abundance of generally friendly attitude in the GOF, which makes a decision very difficult, the vote for this award can also be based on individual acts of kindness you experienced from members of the GOF.

Friendly Member Awards (15 drafts total):


















Malte279

  • The Circle
  • The Gang of Five
  • *
    • Posts: 15608
    • View Profile
    • http://www.ineinemlandvorunsererzeit.de.vu
Helpful Member Awards:
The Helpful Member Award is meant to go to the one whom the majority considered most engaged whenever it comes to supporting others when it comes to providing materials (e.g. pictures, music, information) asked for by others.

Helpful Member Awards (12 drafts total):














Malte279

  • The Circle
  • The Gang of Five
  • *
    • Posts: 15608
    • View Profile
    • http://www.ineinemlandvorunsererzeit.de.vu
Philosopher Awards:
The Philosopher Award is meant for those whose posts on LBT matters which are perceived as particularly well elaborated, thought through, convincing, triggering discussions etc.

Philosopher Awards (11 drafts total):














Malte279

  • The Circle
  • The Gang of Five
  • *
    • Posts: 15608
    • View Profile
    • http://www.ineinemlandvorunsererzeit.de.vu
Proactive Member Awards:
The Proactive Member Award is meant for those members who are most active if it comes to get new stuff started at the GOF. This includes for example those who make good suggestions for new board sections which have been carried into action or to those who managed to organize activities involving several members of the GOF, but also those who started new LBT webpages or any other LBT related projects which are not quite to be included in the term fanart.

Proactive Member Awards (15 drafts total):


















Malte279

  • The Circle
  • The Gang of Five
  • *
    • Posts: 15608
    • View Profile
    • http://www.ineinemlandvorunsererzeit.de.vu
Role Play Gamer Awards:
The Role Play Gamer Award is to be voted for by the participants of the RPG sections of this board. They are to vote for the one who is contributing by writing the most interesting contributions to the RPGs. The frequency of the contributions, and the sheer devotion to RPGs are other points to be rewarded with this award.

Role Play Gamer Awards (12 drafts total):














Malte279

  • The Circle
  • The Gang of Five
  • *
    • Posts: 15608
    • View Profile
    • http://www.ineinemlandvorunsererzeit.de.vu
Appreciated Member Awards:
Without the constant input and value of our members here at the GOF, we never would have lasted so long, nor would we be as active and prosperous as we are today without their contribution. There are many of you who keep the GOF going every day through your input and you deserve to be recognized for this too. Therefore the "Appreciated Member" award is to be voted upon after the decision for all other awards has been made. Only those who were not elected for any of the other awards can be nominated for the Appreciated Member Award.

Appreciated Member Awards (7 drafts total):















And now with the "shiny stuff" posted I want to give special thanks to MurMur his many posts in the Caption this section provided awesome material to work with when creating these award drafts. The great supply of suitable images provided by you made the award creating a lot easier this year :yes


Ducky123

  • *feels like Pterano*
  • Member+
  • Littlefoot
  • *
    • Posts: 7485
    • View Profile
Wow! So many drafts to choose from.. If I receive any awards, I'll have a hard time choosing one.
A big thanks to MurMur from me, too, and I hope he'll return soon contributing to the award voting and posting new captions :yes
Inactive, probably forever.


Pangaea

  • Member+
  • Cera
  • *
    • Posts: 4434
  • Contemplator of Deep Time
    • View Profile
Yikes, it's voting time again already? :blink:

Do you think two weeks is going to be enough time to collect a sufficient number of votes, considering how sparse member activity has been on the GOF?

I'll be participating, all right, though I'm going to have a heck of a hard time deciding who to nominate, considering I've barely been here in the last year. :unsure:

And wow, love the award drafts. :DD Seriously, there are some terrific images here. Kudos to the award makers and everyone who helped them. :smile Just out of curiosity, though, why is the font on several of them different than usual? (Personally I don't think it looks as good as the more boldfaced text of previous years' awards, but that may just be me.)

And hey, Ducky123! Your former avatar is on one of the RPG drafts! :lol



Pronounced "pan-JEE-uh". Spelled with three A's. Represented by a Lystrosaurus.


Ducky123

  • *feels like Pterano*
  • Member+
  • Littlefoot
  • *
    • Posts: 7485
    • View Profile
I noticed :lol

Now than you mention it, Pangaea, I also think it's worth considering to give some less active members more time to decide whom to vote for... Why would there be any need to hurry btw? The year's still far from being at its end :yes
Inactive, probably forever.


Malte279

  • The Circle
  • The Gang of Five
  • *
    • Posts: 15608
    • View Profile
    • http://www.ineinemlandvorunsererzeit.de.vu
I'm sorry this response is late.
Quote
Do you think two weeks is going to be enough time to collect a sufficient number of votes, considering how sparse member activity has been on the GOF?
Yes. Thing is that in the award voting of the last years with three weeks for the initial seven and another week for the appreciated member award things seemed to be rather drawn out. Even with the shorter time there are long periods during which nobody is voting. With the longer time frame it may have sometimes even had the effect of people postponing their votes in the perception that there was so much time left for it anyway. By the end of the voting however the beginning was so long past that some may have barely remembered the beginning of the vote ;)
We therefore decided to cut it down reducing the overall time to three weeks by allowing just two for the original seven characters. The time including two weekends should be sufficient for everyone who wants to participate to make up his or her mind and cast the votes (though of course it is difficult in some categories, but more time doesn't really make making up one's mind much easier).
The way things look so far there may be tie breaking votes this year.
Quote
Just out of curiosity, though, why is the font on several of them different than usual? (Personally I don't think it looks as good as the more boldfaced text of previous years' awards, but that may just be me.)
I absolutely agree with you there. Indeed, I didn't use a different font but failed to set the font to bold type. I think you are right that the bold type looks much better and already I have edited most award drafts so they will be available in bold type before the voting ends (I only need to finish the RPG Awards and then I'll post the bold type versions here).

The end of the voting on the first seven awards is drawing closer. This friday is the last day to cast your votes on those. I want to encourage everyone to participate. Only those who voted themselves on at least six out of the eight categories total (including the appreciated member award) can receive an award themselves and only those who did cast their votes can be elected for the Appreciated member Award (if they haven't been elected for any of the others). Voting and receiving awards is voluntarily of course and not obligatory but the more members participate the better and the more interesting it becomes :yes