When I first saw the reprise of this song in 9 I was pretty unimpressed, ad to this day I still am. I mean, I know with "Big Water" in the title of the film it would be wrong NOT to have the song, but still, it was too different for my liking. The original time they were all scared of it, and it had visuals that definitely appealed to my younger eyes, and it was just amazing. The reprise...was anything but. They were singing it happily, had goofy expressions on their faces, and...it felt like an insult to the original song. Plus, there were three other songs as it was, and there aren't more then 3 songs in an LBT film...
Call me nitpicky, but it just felt like pointless filler material and a lame rip-off of a really good song. My respect for theoriginal song dropped a few notches when I heard this version, but by now I know I shouldn't let something like that ruin my view of something I like.
Also, MarzGurl's review of this part was hilarious! "I braced myself for a song, but what I got I wasn't quite expecting..."