I like both, so this was a hard decision. I chose Anndi McAfee, simply because her singing voice was superb over Hutson. Hutson had a very high voice, which you can that Cera was at a young age. This was something I found to be be quite great to hear. As she change actress, her mood would change, too, since she would be much older. So, both actresses filled the spot as she progressed through life fairly well. However, in terms of singing, definitely McAfee has more experience in that part, and pulled off the sing-a-longs so well.