Kosh and Mr. Clubtail

[Nanotyrannus]

I like to split the clubtails in the series up even further than just Kosh and Mr. Clubtail; the way I see it, Mr. Clubtail is the specific clubtail in V, XI and XII, Kosh is a one-off character in the one episode and the Rob Paulsen and Jeff Bennett clubtails from the third movie and 'The Amazing Threehorn Girl' respectively are their own distinct "characters" as well.

[aabicus (LettuceBacon&Tomato)]

Unlike the rest of y'all, Mr. Clubtail and Kosh will always be the same character to me. If Littlefoot can change voice actors eight times, Mr. Clubtail can once, and his personality never changed to the degree that I couldn't believe it was the same sometimes-cranky old dinosaur.

I just prefer one long-running side character over multiple extremely minor, half-baked ones who look exactly alike.

[somerandomfangirl]

Unlike the rest of y'all, Mr. Clubtail and Kosh will always be the same character to me. If Littlefoot can change voice actors eight times, Mr. Clubtail can once, and his personality never changed to the degree that I couldn't believe it was the same sometimes-cranky old dinosaur.

I just prefer one long-running side character over multiple extremely minor, half-baked ones who look exactly alike.

Yeah I see them as the same character too although to be fair I haven't put that much thought into it. There are multiple occasions where characters have changed voice actors (especially in the shift between their movie and TV series appearances) so that isn't enough for me to say that's a different character. I suppose the different mannerisms might be due to whatever mood he's in that day.

[Gentle Sharptooth]

When Mr. Clubtail says, “Splashing around needlessly, for shame!” You have to take into account he and the other inhabitants of The Great Valley are under great duress; their water source is stopped, and low, and they all save The Gang of Five, are in survival mind set, which makes people edgier and harsher.

[Troud]

(Ten years later. . .)
The series has an ankylosaur character named "Kosh". That leads me to ask a question. Has the voting window passed the pebbles by yet?