21
Silver Screen / Castle: My Season 4 Reviews
« on: September 20, 2011, 01:00:00 PM »
So I dunno if anyone here watches Castle or not, but it's probably my favorite show on the networks now, especially after the amazing finale of Season 3. I've decided to review each episode of Season 4 now as a bit of a hobby and to hone my reviewing skills. I'll also be looking at the cases presented, as that's part of why I watch it in the first place, as it's really good mystery writing. So here we go, I'm gonna try and be consistent with this, and get all the way through. Tonight was the premier, and was called:
RISE
Review: So for those who watch the show (and those who don't), Detective Kate Beckett had been shot at the very end of the third season during Captain Montgomery's funeral, and her survival was left ambiguous. Rather significantly, Castle admitted to Kate that he loved her, but it ended right there and left the viewer hanging. The season finale was quite frankly superb, and was a masterful combination of plot weaving, character development, and suspense. I had high expectations for the season opener, and though I don't think it quite measured up to what I'd been hoping for, it came pretty close.
The season premier picked up at the hospital, with EMTs flocking all around what for all we know is a dying Beckett. It was frantic, with lots of cuts to keep the tension on. I really liked the opening, and although you knew she wasn't going to die (Stana Katic is on contract for this season after all), you could still feel the frenetic pace they were going for here.
This episode quickly became very serious, and lacked a lot of the humor most Castle fans are used to. Kate's shooter disappears without a trace, leaving only his gun, and Castle is forced to work the case alongside Ryan and Esposito, but they come up empty handed after three months of dead ends. There was an interesting dynamic established toward the beginning of this episode, when Kate and Castle meet in the hospital and Kate claims she remembers nothing about the shooting, or Castle's words to her. First off, the way Nathan Fillion acted during this part was tremendous, as you could just see everything in his eyes. All his disappointment and depression were right there, and Fillion did a phenomenal job in capturing that. He was crushed, and he portrayed it. He becomes a little bitter at her for not calling him during those three months, and it's only when she contacts him again in order to pick up the trail of the case he'd been working do we really see just how much she's changed as a character.
Beckett initially feared looking into her mother's case, as she didn't want to become obsessed with it again, and here we clearly see that obsession coming to the surface now. She outright states that unless she wraps up her mother's case (by finding the guy who shot at her), she won't know who she is anymore, and this is way different from the Beckett we're all used to. I was uncertain how to read into this at first, as part of me is like "yeah! Let's go get this guy!" but part of me started having second thoughts when she accused that fire investigator of falsifying his records and covering up the real cause of a warehouse fire they were looking into, even though she had no evidence. This is definitely not the Kate Beckett I remember, who would never make accusations like that without solid proof. I thought this was very well done on the part of the writers, as they're now making us question if she should really be pursuing this avenue, or if she's just grasping at straws with nothing to go on.
Now that Roy Montgomery is dead, the precint has a new captain, portrayed by Penny Johnson. She is NOT Montgomery, for those who were hoping for another supportive captain. Instead, she's very cold, formal, and demanding. I sort of felt that if anything, she'll actually work to bring Beckett and Castle closer together, due to her refusal to allow Beckett to look into her own shooting. At the same time though, Castle received some info during this episode that told him that Beckett would be safe provided she dropped the investigation, and thus he's trying to dissuade her (at least for now) from pursuing it. So we're really given a three way battle here, with Beckett wanting to catch her shooter, Captain Gates ordering her to drop it, and Castle sort of taking a "let's focus on your job first, and we'll get this guy someday" approach. I don't think this is going to last, and it'll be interesting to see where the writers plan to take this from here. I thought Penny Johnson delivered a strong enough role, and she'll be an interesting sort of counterpoint to Beckett throughout this season.
We also learn a rather large surprise at the very end... Beckett lied... and she does in fact remember everything about the shooting, including what Castle said to her. This was what I was hoping for, as it makes the story now infinitely more interesting, because she KNOWS how he feels, but outright lied about it. This is definitely going to come back at some point this season, and I'm very much looking forward to seeing just how Castle discovers this one. It'll also give the season an arc, and one that will hang over the heads of viewers as it progresses, cropping up here and there and coming out with what I'm guessing will be a bang later on. Castle hasn't generally had an overarching arc, just the whole Beckett gradually uncovering more about her mother's murder thing which came to a head last season. The writers are sending a message here that they're going to focus on this arc, something new for the show.
The Case: This week's murder mystery dealt with the murder of a famous celebrity/debutante (celebutante is the term they used), Sonya Gilbert. She was found shot six times in the chest and throat on her bed, with the killer using a pillow as a crude silencer. The real mystery started when it was found out that her apartment had a security system on it that was only deactivated once that entire night, and that was when Sonya and her boyfriend, Dale, arrived home. It was on the entire night, and deactivated again when Dale left in the morning, but Sonya's time of death was during the night, so logically, it had to be Dale, right?
Well it would be too simple if that were the case (and terrible writing for that matter!), and questions began to arise when Ryan and Esposito wondered why Dale killed Sonya, and then stuck around for another six hours or so before leaving. That just didn't make sense, as usually killers flee immediately. Dale claimed they both passed out upon arriving at her apartment, and he woke up to find her dead with the gun in his hand. Panicking, he had fled the scene, taking the gun with him, thus explaining why it was on him when he was arrested. So how had the killer defeated the security system? Further investigation showed that both Dale and Sonya had been roofied via their drinks, and both were probably quite unconscious during the murder. When Castle finally convinced Beckett to focus on the case rather than finding her shooter, the answers became clear.
Spoilers ahead! Read at own risk!
This was a great case, and though it wasn't focused on as heavily due to the Beckett plot being explored, it was still in the vein of classic Castle murder mystery, and was a strong opener for the season, and helped shore up my doubts about where the show might be heading from here, as it proved the writers still got it when it comes to the murder mystery.
In Conclusion: Overall, I felt a little confused by the more serious atmosphere of the episode at first, though I've read the familiar vein of humor will be returning in future episodes this season. This opener was dark, serious, and took a good look at characters that left the viewer with many questions about how things will go from here. My rating for "Rise" will be an 8 out of 10, as I felt that even though it wasn't your familiar Castle formula, it's now really focused on story, and that's just as good. Even though I felt some things were lacking (I guess I just want that old Castle feel back), I still felt that it was a good opening, though didn't quite live up to the anticipation I'd been having since that amazing cliffhanger in May. Either way, a solid effort, and 8/10 is my rating for "Rise".
RISE
Review: So for those who watch the show (and those who don't), Detective Kate Beckett had been shot at the very end of the third season during Captain Montgomery's funeral, and her survival was left ambiguous. Rather significantly, Castle admitted to Kate that he loved her, but it ended right there and left the viewer hanging. The season finale was quite frankly superb, and was a masterful combination of plot weaving, character development, and suspense. I had high expectations for the season opener, and though I don't think it quite measured up to what I'd been hoping for, it came pretty close.
The season premier picked up at the hospital, with EMTs flocking all around what for all we know is a dying Beckett. It was frantic, with lots of cuts to keep the tension on. I really liked the opening, and although you knew she wasn't going to die (Stana Katic is on contract for this season after all), you could still feel the frenetic pace they were going for here.
This episode quickly became very serious, and lacked a lot of the humor most Castle fans are used to. Kate's shooter disappears without a trace, leaving only his gun, and Castle is forced to work the case alongside Ryan and Esposito, but they come up empty handed after three months of dead ends. There was an interesting dynamic established toward the beginning of this episode, when Kate and Castle meet in the hospital and Kate claims she remembers nothing about the shooting, or Castle's words to her. First off, the way Nathan Fillion acted during this part was tremendous, as you could just see everything in his eyes. All his disappointment and depression were right there, and Fillion did a phenomenal job in capturing that. He was crushed, and he portrayed it. He becomes a little bitter at her for not calling him during those three months, and it's only when she contacts him again in order to pick up the trail of the case he'd been working do we really see just how much she's changed as a character.
Beckett initially feared looking into her mother's case, as she didn't want to become obsessed with it again, and here we clearly see that obsession coming to the surface now. She outright states that unless she wraps up her mother's case (by finding the guy who shot at her), she won't know who she is anymore, and this is way different from the Beckett we're all used to. I was uncertain how to read into this at first, as part of me is like "yeah! Let's go get this guy!" but part of me started having second thoughts when she accused that fire investigator of falsifying his records and covering up the real cause of a warehouse fire they were looking into, even though she had no evidence. This is definitely not the Kate Beckett I remember, who would never make accusations like that without solid proof. I thought this was very well done on the part of the writers, as they're now making us question if she should really be pursuing this avenue, or if she's just grasping at straws with nothing to go on.
Now that Roy Montgomery is dead, the precint has a new captain, portrayed by Penny Johnson. She is NOT Montgomery, for those who were hoping for another supportive captain. Instead, she's very cold, formal, and demanding. I sort of felt that if anything, she'll actually work to bring Beckett and Castle closer together, due to her refusal to allow Beckett to look into her own shooting. At the same time though, Castle received some info during this episode that told him that Beckett would be safe provided she dropped the investigation, and thus he's trying to dissuade her (at least for now) from pursuing it. So we're really given a three way battle here, with Beckett wanting to catch her shooter, Captain Gates ordering her to drop it, and Castle sort of taking a "let's focus on your job first, and we'll get this guy someday" approach. I don't think this is going to last, and it'll be interesting to see where the writers plan to take this from here. I thought Penny Johnson delivered a strong enough role, and she'll be an interesting sort of counterpoint to Beckett throughout this season.
We also learn a rather large surprise at the very end... Beckett lied... and she does in fact remember everything about the shooting, including what Castle said to her. This was what I was hoping for, as it makes the story now infinitely more interesting, because she KNOWS how he feels, but outright lied about it. This is definitely going to come back at some point this season, and I'm very much looking forward to seeing just how Castle discovers this one. It'll also give the season an arc, and one that will hang over the heads of viewers as it progresses, cropping up here and there and coming out with what I'm guessing will be a bang later on. Castle hasn't generally had an overarching arc, just the whole Beckett gradually uncovering more about her mother's murder thing which came to a head last season. The writers are sending a message here that they're going to focus on this arc, something new for the show.
The Case: This week's murder mystery dealt with the murder of a famous celebrity/debutante (celebutante is the term they used), Sonya Gilbert. She was found shot six times in the chest and throat on her bed, with the killer using a pillow as a crude silencer. The real mystery started when it was found out that her apartment had a security system on it that was only deactivated once that entire night, and that was when Sonya and her boyfriend, Dale, arrived home. It was on the entire night, and deactivated again when Dale left in the morning, but Sonya's time of death was during the night, so logically, it had to be Dale, right?
Well it would be too simple if that were the case (and terrible writing for that matter!), and questions began to arise when Ryan and Esposito wondered why Dale killed Sonya, and then stuck around for another six hours or so before leaving. That just didn't make sense, as usually killers flee immediately. Dale claimed they both passed out upon arriving at her apartment, and he woke up to find her dead with the gun in his hand. Panicking, he had fled the scene, taking the gun with him, thus explaining why it was on him when he was arrested. So how had the killer defeated the security system? Further investigation showed that both Dale and Sonya had been roofied via their drinks, and both were probably quite unconscious during the murder. When Castle finally convinced Beckett to focus on the case rather than finding her shooter, the answers became clear.
Spoilers ahead! Read at own risk!
Quote
As it turned out, the only real answer is that the killer was already in the apartment before they got home! As it turned out, Dale's bandmate, Mitch, had also been in a relationship with Sonya, and had urged her to break it off with Dale in favor of him, but she decided to go with Dale instead. Seeking revenge, Mitch entered the apartment (he knew the code to deactive the security system, as he'd been in a relationship with Sonya) before they arrived home, and waited. When they got there, he hid under the bed, suspending himself from the metal frame in a rather clever hiding spot. He waited for them to leave the room, spiked their drinks while they were gone, and then waited for them to fall asleep. Once asleep, he slipped out, shot Sonya, wiped his prints clean, placed the gun in Dale's hand, and then, instead of exiting the apartment (as he knew he'd have to deactive the security, and that would tip the cops off to someone being there ahead of time), he slid back under the bed and waited several hours for Dale to awaken. When Dale awoke, he panicked, exited the apartment (deactiving the security in the process and setting him up as the killer), and Mitch was able to make his escape afterward, now that the security was down.
There was a clear spot under Sonya's bed where there should have been blood stains, and it was deduced someone had been hiding under there the entire time. Fingerprints belonging to Mitch were found on the bedframe, and that wrapped this case up.
This was a great case, and though it wasn't focused on as heavily due to the Beckett plot being explored, it was still in the vein of classic Castle murder mystery, and was a strong opener for the season, and helped shore up my doubts about where the show might be heading from here, as it proved the writers still got it when it comes to the murder mystery.
In Conclusion: Overall, I felt a little confused by the more serious atmosphere of the episode at first, though I've read the familiar vein of humor will be returning in future episodes this season. This opener was dark, serious, and took a good look at characters that left the viewer with many questions about how things will go from here. My rating for "Rise" will be an 8 out of 10, as I felt that even though it wasn't your familiar Castle formula, it's now really focused on story, and that's just as good. Even though I felt some things were lacking (I guess I just want that old Castle feel back), I still felt that it was a good opening, though didn't quite live up to the anticipation I'd been having since that amazing cliffhanger in May. Either way, a solid effort, and 8/10 is my rating for "Rise".