Hey, guys,
As some of you might know, I'm working on a LBT fanfic involving time traveling, and I was wondering if any of you guys have any speculation regarding the location of the Great Valley.
For me, I believe that the Great Valley is really just Ashley Valley, in Uintah County, Utah. Like the Great Valley, Ashley Valley is a lush green valley surrounded by mountains. There are three (and before human intervention, five) waterways running through it, and there are two big lakes. The Ashely Valley also contains the nearby villages of Vernal, Jensen, and Maeser. There are at least three state parks in the region, and the National Dinosaur Monument is nearby. According to fossil records, this place was home to many dinosaurs in the Jurassic and early Cretaceous period. Because most of the species in LBT can be found in the Southwestern United States, this is one of the most likely candidates for the location of the Great Valley. Secondly, this valley, in the early Cretaceous period, the Western Interior Seaway would have been close by. This could be the "Big Water." Also, the place seems like a place where it would be reasonable to receive snow sometimes, but no all the time.
Also, the size of the valley seems reasonable for the population. It is also surrounded by mountains (Uintah Mountains, Split Mountain, etc). Although there are some "oases" in the surrounding areas, most of the surrounding area is pretty dry. Here's a pic of the valley. Notice the large river at the right and the lake in the upper left corner.
It also struck me how a lot of the locations actually resemble LBT locations. Take a look at the following picture:
and compare it to this one:
(btw: Thanks Malte for the above pic)
If you look carefully, they sort of resemble each other. If you look to the right side of the first pic, you can see a river. If the distance, you can see a waterfall.
Here's another pic:
I'll explain:
1: Real-life picture of Ashley valley. It's nothing short of magnificent.
2: Picture form Google Earth. It looks like a beautiful place to live.
3: In the nearby town of Vernal, dinosaurs are celebrated figures, as shown by this sign.
4: The National Dinosaur Monument is located not far away from the valley and is a popular tourist destination.
Anyways, the above are just my thoughts
. Feel free to voice the possible locations of the Great Valley in the responses. I do not believe that the two places actually called "The Great Valley" in NY and PA are likely candidates. I live in the "Great Valley" in PA. Although it is a beautiful place to live, there are just way too many trees and not enough rivers