The Gang of Five
Beyond the Mysterious Beyond => The Party Room => Topic started by: Noname on September 13, 2009, 02:59:41 PM
-
In this game, we take two characters, and have them fight each other. One person posts the pair of characters who will fight, and the next poster says who they think will win and why, then posts a new pair who will fight.
Example:
Red Claw vs. Topsy
Red Claw wins because he is much larger and stronger, and can disable or even kill Topsy in just one bite!
I'll start
Doc vs. Bron
-
Doc's got a wicked tail fast as lightning. Bron's battle against Sharpteeth was slightly less epic. Doc wins.
An underwater battle between Ducky and that aquatic lizard thing, the first creature we saw in the first film.
-
Ducky wins, because she is larger and had limbs which can do more damage than that lizard-thing could do to her.
Topsy vs. the leader of Tippy's herd.
-
Ooooh, tough. I'd have to say Topsy, just 'cause he's tenacious as anything and wouldn't back off.
How about Petrie VS Guido?
-
Guido, because he is larger than Petrie.
Pterano vs. Littlefoot
-
Pterano. He can fly, and has a sharp beak. Not to mention he's got the mentality for it as well.
Grandpa Longneck vs. the narrator
-
Grandpa Longneck would win... because the narrator is a disembodied voice and thus, cannot fight... although Grandpa Longneck IS the narrator in movie 6.
Dil vs. Crocodile in movie 10.
-
The primitive crocodile looked A LOT more bigger and more fierce then Dil. Sorry, but the woman is just no match for that beast in the tenth sequel.
Pterano vs Sierra
*grabs popcorn, munches away*
-
I would have to call it a draw... but if one of them absolutely HAD to win... Pterano. He might have a longer beak... not sure... longer range?
Here's one that I think we know the answer to, but I just want to see the result anyway...
Topsy vs. Tria.
-
It kind of depends on the situation. :p I guess all Tria could do was sweet talk to her mate and Mr. Three Horn would melt. :lol But if that doesn't work, then my bet is on Daddy Tops. Tria I think CAN fight, we just never see her do so. She has that fighting attitude anyway.
Hyp vs. Mutt
-
(Tria was SO dead! :lol )
Mutt. He is larger, and his species, a Muttaburasaurus grows to be much bigger than a Hypsilophodon ever does.
Ducky's Mother vs. Tippy's Mother.
-
(Honestly Noname, I think it would be a close call for Tria, I think she could fight Tops back, but in the long run, Tops would win.)
Depends on where they are. If they were near water, Ducky's mom would win. If they were on a flat landscape with no water, Tippy's mom would win.
Cera vs Little Foot
-
(Tops is like, 25% larger or so... and his horns are clearly larger too. I compared it to a fight between a cow and a bull.)
Well, we have seen them fight... Cera kinda won that fight... but Littlefoot wasn't thinking straight... and by now, he is a lot larger than her, and will get even more so... so I would say, Littlefoot.
Tria vs. Dil.
-
(I always thought Cera was larger. Littlefoot was bigger than her in the first movie, but he certainly doesn't look even bigger now, in the later films. Cera looks larger, though I'll have to check to be sure.)
I'd say Tippy's mom. She's likely too large and heavy for Dil to successfully drag into the water, if they were near a lake. And if Dil confronted her head-on, she would need to contend with the tail. Even though Tippy's mom's spikes are small, a blow with her tail alone would cause damage. And Dil isn't exactly swift on her feet.
Chomper vs Guido
-
Chomper would win IF he could catch Guido. Guido could only hope to escape, not win.
And since you accidently said "Tippy's mom vs. Dil" instead of the actual "Tria vs. Dil", I'll ask it again... I'll admit that I make a mistake occasionally as well, such as reading "Grandma Longneck" as "Grandpa Longneck."
Tria vs. Dil.
-
(Oh whoops. lol Thanks for pointing that out.)
I'd say Tria. She's not only larger, but she has longer legs than Dil and could run faster. Sure Dil's jaws could patch a punch, but not if she can't catch her prey. And Tria has those sharp horns and likely could easily impale Dil if she had the chance.
Mr. Clubtail vs Bron
-
Bron would win due to sheer size, but only with difficulty.
Doc vs. Red Claw.
-
Doc would win, he is no legend for nothing :DD .
Ducky's mother vs Ms. Maia
-
We don't know much about Ms. Maia... but what little we see of her would lead me to believe that Ducky's mother would win.
Ducky vs. Guido.
-
Ducky, 'cause Guido had that thing about water, he didn't even want to go in it.
Bron vs. That third sharptooth from V (not chomper's parents)
-
It would be close, but I think Bron would win, due to his larger size.
Sue vs. Littlefoot's mother.
-
It is a close battle. But I'll give it to Sue.
Sue's only advantage is that she is larger than Littlefoot's mother. In addition, she is not averse to using violence.
LBT 1 Sharptooth vs. Doc
-
Close battle, but Doc would win, just like the time he beat that tyrannosaurus in Grandpa Longneck's story.
Ichy vs. Guido
-
Icthy.
Both are roughly the same size (~2 feet long)
Guido cannot fly like Icthy and he lacks Icthy's natural weapon of talons and a stiletto like beak.
Chomper's father vs LBT 1 Sharptooth.
-
Probably the first one... he had seemingly supernatural abilities.
Bron vs. Sue
-
Sue is ginormous, plus Bron might have issues with hurting a female.
The narrator vs. Petrie's imaginary friend
-
The narrator would win because... he exists! :lol
And how do we know that some of the sharpteeth Bron fought weren't female? :lol
Anyway...
Hyp vs. Ruby's father.
-
Ruby's father
Ruby's father probably has hand-to-hand combat experience (migratory herd and he has to defend himself and his family from threats). In addition he is substantially larger than Hyp.
Pterano vs. Icthy
-
Pterano
He is larger than Ichy, has a longer beak, clawed hands in addition to his wings, and his vision seems normal. Ichy on the other paw is cross-eyed, only has feathers on his wings (no claws), and is small compard to Pterano. We saw what Spike could do to him :lol!
Ducky vs. Petrie
-
CT I just wanted to add something about Pterano vs. Icthy. He's also a VERY skilled hand-to-hand combatant (Revenge I).
-------------------
I call it a draw.
Petrie can attack in a 3d space and attack at odd angles. Also, he can drop objects on Ducky or even pick her up and drop her.
Ducky is probably stronger than Petrie and she could pull him down. In addition, Petrie's bones are probably less resistant to breakage due to them being hollow to allow flight.
So the conclusion is that, if Ducky does not manage ground Petrie quickly. Petrie wins. If Petrie is on the ground and trapped, Ducky wins.
Ms. Swimmer (Ducky's Mother) vs. Mutt's father.
-
Ms. Swimmer
From what we saw of Mutt's father in LBT III, he seems to be a coward. Ms. Swimmer could probably just intimidate the dude and the battle would be over :p.
Cera vs. Shorty
-
Shorty. He is probably stronger and can hit her with rocks using his tail from a distance.
Rhett vs. Shorty.
-
Shorty,Rhett would run when the battle is halfway over because he would have gotten his tail kicked(butt kicked) by then.
here's a tough one:
Littlefoot's Mother vs Bron
-
Bron. Not so hard. We see that he is larger than she is in the flashback, and when he was bitten by a tyrannosaurus, he didn't die. She did. It might only be "tough" because on intense political correctness pressure to not find the female being weaker.
Sue vs. Topsy.
-
Sue. She is MUCH larger than Topsy and she has greater reach with her tail and she is not averse to using violence to solve problems.
Hyp vs. Guido
-
Hyp. He is SO much larger than Guido.
Okay, here's one.
Littlefoot vs. Ali
-
Littlefoot. He is larger, and the disparity is even more obvious in the TV series.
Spike vs. Cera.
-
Okay, as much as I like Cera, I know her faults. One of which is rushing into battle without planning. Spike has proven himself to be smarter in several different areas of combat. As such, his brains would beat Cera's brawn. So Spike wins.
Also, on another note, are you SURE Littlefoot would win against Ali? After all, his feelings could get in the way. ;)
Okay, here's another...
Ducky vs. Big Daddy
-
Ali's feelings would get in the way long before his would, I am sure!
Big Daddy would probably win because Ducky really isn't that violent.
Rinkus vs. Sierra.
-
Sierra
Rinkus may be smarter but Sierra is stronger and larger. Not to mention Sierra is extremely violent. Chances are he would have no qualms about gouging out Rinkus's eyes or some other brutal act.
-----------------
Bron vs. LBT V sharptooth
-
Bron would win that one, though it would be a tough fight.
The original Sharptooth vs. All the sequel sharpteeth
-
All the sequel Sharpteeth.
Though the LBT 1 sharptooth was supernaturally tough, he'd have a hard time dealing with multiple sharpteeth who could double or even triple team him. In addition, some of the sequel sharpteeth were no slouches.
Rhett vs. Ali
-
Rhett's a flaming wimp who's never accomplished anything. Ali survived the Journey through the Mists and faced off against a Belly dragger and a Sharpbeak. Rhett would be confident of his victory, then get owned in about five minutes.
Big Daddy vs. Great Hideous Beast from TV episode Stranger From the Mysterious Above
-
(Rhett may be a wimp, but Ali is so gullible in that episode, he'd probably bluff his way to victory, and if it came to strength, I'm sure he'd win. Simply being chased around by a crocodile and a bird doesn't make you tougher.)
Big Daddy. He's tough for his size.
Topsy/Mr. Threehorn vs. Kosh/ Mr. Clubtail.
-
(It'd sure as heck make me tougher if I got chased by a giant crocodile and lived)
I'd say Mr. Clubtail because as an ankylosaurus he's covered in protective armor plates that prevent him from virtually any attack. Plus his "bopper" is more than an effective offensive weapon. He cold shatter ankles with that thing.
Shorty vs. Cera
EDIT: Drat, done already. One second, got to think of a new one.
Got it. The gigantic flyer from LBT 7 versus Sue's mate
-
(Just being chased by something makes no difference, except when it comes to knowing how to run away. I'm sure Rhett was chased before... heck, Chomper kinda 'chases' him off too.)
Sue's mate wins easily. Besides being the single largest animal in the whole series, he has also probably strong enough to knock that Quetzelcoatalus out of the sky in one hit, and probably shatter it like it was made of toothpicks.
Chomper's father vs. Original sharptooth.
-
Original Sharptooth. Both of Chomper's parent got defeated by a single Sharptooth, one whom the original Sharptooth would have wiped the floor with.
Ducky and Petrie with Uzis (http://www.gangoffive.net/index.php?topic=4240) versus any other character.
-
(Well, Chomper's dad beat that one in the end, but was knocked back first.)
Probably Ducky and Petrie :lol Unless those Uzis are really that small! :DD
Tria vs. Littlefoot's mom.
-
Littlefoot's Mother. If she was able to take down The Original Sharptooth while being wounded, she can handle just about ANY other dinosaur out there.
Okay, here's another.
Ruby vs. Cera
-
Cera,she would easily take Ruby down with a charge
Cera(charging):BANZAI!!!!!!
Littlefoot vs Rhett.
-
Same as Ali vs. Rhett. Rhett's still a wimp, and Littlefoot's done even more than Ali. The fight would be two minutes instead of five.
What about Shorty vs. Rhett?
-
That would be like unleashing Cera on him :lol. Rhett is such a wimp that Shorty would kick the snot out of him easily.
Mr. Threehorn vs. LBT 1 Sharptooth
-
Land Before Time 1 sharptooth. It killed an animal larger than himself and Topsy combined... Littlefoot's mom.
Pat (before being burned) vs. grandpa Longneck.
-
Grandpa Longneck, he has more energy in him,Pat is almost as old as The Old One from IV and near that age I'd imagine you would be pretty weak.
Original Sharptooth vs the yellowbellies(they must die for being the worst LBT characters).
-
The YellowBellies are very, very, very dead, no matter what stupid tricks they pull. It makes me sad to think that the movies ended on that note...
Ruby's father vs. Screech OR Thud.
-
:lol lunch time for Screech and Thud. It MIGHT be close fight, but I really don't know if Ruby's father can fight, he just might be able to run fast, hence his species name...but I really don't know...
Original Sharptooth vs Red Claw
-
Good one...
Original Sharptooth wins, as we haven't seen Red Claw fight very much, and he can be beaten with fruit! Really...
Red Claw vs. Bron
-
If Red Claw can be beaten with fruit, this is an easy win for Bron :lol!
Tria vs. Ms. Maia
-
Eh, I think Tria would win this one, I mean Ms. Maia just throws Ducky out of her nest, but we never see Ms. Maia fight. :p
Cera vs. Shorty
-
I think we did this one...
Shorty. Cera is a bit smaller, and Shorty can attack at a range, before she can hit him. Plus, she only attacks in one way, and can be dodged easily enough.
Tria vs. Tippy's mom.
-
Tippy's Mom,Tria could could charge at her but Tippy's Mother could wait for her to get close enough while doing so and do a well-timed tail whip put that with the damage her tail spikes would cause.
Grandma Longneck vs Grandpa Longneck.
-
Grandpa longneck clearly wins... he even states that Grandma is not as strong as she once was and that if he died in the fourth movie, no one would be able to protect him, except for Ali's herd.
Pat vs. Grandpa longneck.
-
Grandpa Longneck.
Pat's severely burned leg would limit his mobility and agility.
Sierra vs Hyp
-
Poor Hyp would be running for his life with someone like Sierra at his tail. :p In short, Hyp= Epic fail on this one....
Hyp vs Little Foot
-
Littlefoot is much heavier than Hyp. Not to mention smarter and braver. Hyp's toast.
Sierra vs. Ozzie
-
Ozzie is larger and probably stronger on the ground... he will win If he can catch Sierra.
Ruby vs. Ali.
-
Ali,she's heavier,no one knows if Ruby can fight.
Pterano vs Mr.Threehorn.
-
He he can catch Pterano, Topsy would maul him!
Mr. Thicknose vs. Tria.
-
that must be embarissing, Mr.Thicknose would be beat up by a woman,but I wouldn't be surprised.
Dil vs Ali .
-
Well, Mr. Thicknose is really, really old... if he were her age, he'd beat Tria, I'm sure.
Ali would be eaten by Dil, until Ali grows up... then it's like, ALI SMASH! or stomp... :lol
Mr. Clubtail vs. Tria.
-
Mr clubtail is slower but more powerful and that says alot ,Tria may be able to charge him but unless she can flip him over ,she's toast.
Sue vs her boyfriend.
-
Her boyfriend... he's COLOSSAL... a lot larger than even her!
Littlefoot's mother v. Sue's boyfriend... although I think we can guess...
-
Sue's boyfriend, he's larger and probably stronger heck, if he fought Littlefoot's Mother he'll crush her.
Pat vs The Old One(from LBT4 not the TV show).
-
Even with his burn, he would probably still win, as he managed to fight a tyrannosaurus...
Tria vs Pat.
-
Size dosen't matter, Tria would bring Pat down and no one likes being knocked on their butt over and over.
Littlefoot's Mother vs Red Claw.
-
Red Claw would kill her like the original one did.
As for Tria and Pat... I think he would beat her, but his burned foot would be a liability. She can't even REACH his rear, if you look at how high up the Sauropods stand.
Red Claw vs. Pack of raptors in third film.
-
Red Claw is just going to go jurassic park on them and throw' em around like rag dolls.
Ducky vs Grandpa Longneck(hint: to figure this one out remember that size dosen't always matter.)
-
Draw.
Ducky is much more agile and faster than Grandpa Longneck. Thus she can evade most if not all of his attacks. However, IF Grandpa Longneck lands a hit, it's an instant KO.
-
Ducky would be unable to hurt him...
Anyway, since Serris didn't ask a new one, I'll post one.
Littlefoot's mother vs. Raptors from third film.
-
those raptors will take out Littlefoot's mother even if she can manage to fend off a few they'll overwhelm her and kill her.
Spiketail Leader vs Tippy's Mother.
-
The leader wins; that's how he likely got the position to begin with.
Tippy's mother vs. Screech & Thud.
-
Screech and Thud, their agile predators after all.
All the Sharpteeth vs All the Great Valley Dinosaurs.
-
The GVG dinosaurs hands down. :p It's because of those pesky kids! :anger (:lol)
Original Sharptooth vs Doc
-
Doc, but it would be an EPIC battle.
Chomper's parents vs. Redclaw and Original Sharptooth.
-
they would be evenly matched but the Original Sharptooth would take all of them down.
Grandpa Longneck vs old age.
-
Sorry, but no mortal can defeat mortality :neutral.
Ducky vs. Tricia
-
Tricia(cute baby voice): Tricia SMASH!! no seriously.
what would happen if Littlefoot failed, Littlefoot vs famine(starvation).
-
Tricia is already larger, so she would probably win. Ducky has no combat skill that we know of... or at least, very little. Tricia probably instinctively charges things, although she is a lot nicer than Cera ever was.
Oh, and famine would eventually kill Littlefoot.
Mr. Thicknose vs. Tippy's mother.
-
Tippy's mother will take Mr. Thicknose down with a swift tail whip.
Ducky vs Petrie.
-
Ducky would only be able to win if she can catch Petrie. I don't think Petrie would win, but he could avoid losing.
Ducky's mom vs. Tria.
-
Tria is MUCH larger and heavier than Ms. Swimmer In addition, Tria has an inherent weapon (horns).
On the other side, Ms. Swimmer can probably evade easier and her tail can probably inflict serious injury. Not to mention, she can enter the water to evade Tria or use an improvised weapon like a large rock or a tree branch.
------------------------
I would say Ms. Swimmer even though it would be difficult. Yes, Tria can charge but that literally her only method of attack. Ms. Swimmer can tail whip, kick, throw objects or use a crude club. Not to mention she can probably evade better.
------------------------
Sue vs. LBT 1 Sharptooth
-
Sue would win. Though that would be one exciting battle. She would probably smash him with her foot after knocking him down just to make sure she would win. ;)
Okay, here's an interesting one.
Tricia vs. Lizzie
-
Lizzie would win if she fights Tricia soon; if Tricia grows too much, she would win.
I also think that Sue would be killed by the original sharptooth; that guy was TOUGH... Sue's mate would kill him, though.
Chomper's Mother vs. Tria.
-
Depends if Chomper's Mother was hungry or not. If she was, she might win, but if just searching for Chomper, then Tria would win.
Ozzy vs Ichy vs Strut vs Dil. (And maybe even vs Rinkus vs Sierra :lol )
-
Dil would probably win that, given her size and species. :DD
Littlefoot's mother vs. Mother longneck in movie 9
-
The LBT9 longneck mother might win that one since she's larger.
Littlefoot's Mother vs. Ali's Mother.
-
We don't know enough about Ali's mother to judge, but I'd say Littlefoot's mother based on the fact that she CAN fight and we know it... although she died in that battle.
Mr. Clubtail vs. Mr. Thicknose.
-
Just BUMPing this thread, to put it nearer to the new one...
-
Mr. Thicknose doesn't seem like a fighter, so I'll go with Mr. Clubtail.
How about Littlefoot versus Shorty?
-
Probably Shorty. He seems more experienced in it... although that could just be for show.
Ali vs. Cera.
-
Ali is WAY too much of a wimp for Cera. >.>
Ducky vs Tickles
-
Ducky would win because of her larger size.
Ali vs. Shorty. And please don't have Ali win because you like her more and/or she is a girl and you want to see a "reverse stereotype."
-
I'd say Shorty. While Ali has done a lot of traveling, she has always been with her herd. Shorty has more experience being out in the open all alone, and if he's survived as long as he did then that's pretty impressive.
Here's an interesting one:
Rooter versus Yellow Bellies (I had to do this one :bang )
-
Rooter would beat a Yellow Belly in a one-on-one match. He would never beat the whole horde of them. Man that last movie was weird... :blink:
Tria vs. Dil.
-
Oh man, this would be a fight I actually would want to sit down and bring popcorn to. ^^ hehe
It -might- be a close fight, but I think Tria can have the guts and brains to outsmart Dil. :D
-
I think you are right that Tria would win, but mainly because of Dil's bad vision. If Tria had to defend Cera or Tricia, I can see her being motivated to win.
Anyway, your turn, Rat Girl. If you don't want to go, I can name another match for you.
-
Oops...sorry...
Tippi vs. Spike
-
Hmm.
Spike. It is known that Spike can perform a meteor smash (Super Smash terminology for an attack that shoots an opponent straight down). He did it on Icthy.
Tippy...he's been with a traveling herd so he may have had some combat experience but it seems that Spike is quite a bit stronger.
I would have to say Tippy because Spike might get distracted by food.
--------------------
Pterano vs. Ruby
-
Pterano by a longshot. He can fly and is probably a heck of a lot smarter than Ruby.
Ducky versus all of the Tinysaurus including Big Daddy.
-
Big Daddy alone would beat poor Ducky. All of the Tinysaurs against her... poor Ducky.
One of the "Dome Heads" from movies one and four vs. Screech.
-
If Screech is smart enough, dinnertime for him! Otherwise, that domehead would end up crushing poor Screech.
Ali vs. Ruby
-
Ali; she is larger than Ruby, although if Ruby ran away, the little sauropod would be unable to catch her.
Ruby vs. Tippy.
-
BUMP
-
Ruby, no question asked. Do I really need to explain this one?
Swooper vs. Pterano
-
Pterano. Swooper is old, blind, and looks like he is a decaying mummy. :blink:
Bron vs. Saro.
-
I'll just say Bron. I'll let someone else suggest the next one.
-
Cera vs Ali
-
Easy win! Cera is a**-kickin' material, and Ali's such a sissy :p.
Petrie vs. Guido (this should get interesting :lol)
-
Guido, IF he can catch Petrie. One is like twice the size of the other.
The Old One vs. Grandma Longneck.
-
I'm rootin' for Grandma, though I'm sure both would end up with a broken hip, to say the least :lol.
Tricia vs. Tickles
-
Tricia is probably tougher than Tickles and her nose horn can do some major damage.
Pterano vs. Ruby
-
Pterano would probably win. Ruby has no real way to fight back, and is probably predisposed to running from a conflict rather than actually fighting.
Bron vs. Original Sharptooth.
-
I'd say Bron, as it is easy to beat on a corpse. Assuming, however, I went back in time to an instance when the original Sharptooth was still living, I have no doubt that Bron would lose. Bron himself made it clear that he is out of combat practice.
Littlefoot:
Eh, hey! How come we haven't seen any Sharpteeth?
Bron:
Sharpteeth are cowards. Look how many of us there are. A Sharptooth would never attack a group this size.
Now, Bron's account of the herd's origin makes it clear that it's been around for some time. Shorty's depiction when the herd was just getting started was certainly younger than how he is shown in the present. He seems to show a lack of experience compared to other Longnecks we've seen in combat. He slid down that mountain to give his tail attack more force to take down that Sharptooth. However, with his size and weight, he cannot recover from sliding down such a decline very quickly, and you all could see the result. He left himself vulnerable with his powerful attack, limiting his defenses, ultimately allowing himself to be wounded in his leg. He had no reason to hurry. The Sharptooth was clearly heading for him, so he didn't have to be as rash as someone protecting another.
As for the original Sharptooth, he is still very much in sinc with battle. His combat skills are even arguably more advanced than any other Sharptooth we have yet seen. Bron seems stronger, but battles have more to do with skill than physical prowess. For example, a teenagrer can subdue a grown man if the teenager has been well trained in the art of battle. In video games, the bosses of levels are nearly always stronger than the hero or heroine, thus resulting in the need for strategy and quick thinking. If Bron wants to win against the Sharptooth, he needs to plan ahead, looking not just at his current actions, but what his actions will result in after they've been carried out. So in short, like I said, I do not believe that Bron would win. If any disagree with my logic, I welcome you to please speak up.
As far as a suggested battle from me, what does someone think about Chomper versus the young orange Sharptooth in the episode "The Lonely Journey"? Chomper may have little desire to fight, but that Sharptooth seems very dependent on his parents' involvement in his battles, so I'm curious to see who someone thinks will win in such a case and why the given victory is chosen. I find this a fair question. Many haven't seen the episodes, I understand that. However, some have not seen all the movies. Have fun.
-
I think the yellow sharptooth would win; he's larger and we don't have much evidence of Chomper practicing killing anything more than some insects ever since he arrived in the Great Valley.
What you say about Bron is true, although there is the possibility he had much practice before he was a part of his herd, or that he would get into fights when he left the herd for a short time... unless he was in sight of his herd for a very long time.
Also the "group" in "a group this size" refers to hundreds or thousands of Sauropods who were gathered in the "crater" valley... not the size of Bron's herd.
How about...
Pat vs. The Old One?
-
Meh, Pat would probably win. :lol: