Let me update on these guys. First off, I still have them. They are just collecting dust in my closet, along with a few other plushies, but I still have them.
I also had two others. They were a bigger version of Littlefoot and Cera. However, I gave those to my nephews. Last I heard, Cera and Littlefoot got chewed up and torn by their dogs. They've probably thrown them away as a result.

Yes, I still hold the critique of "Cera looking at her mustache" to this day.
Finally, thank you for restoring that picture, ImpracticalDino. I thought that was lost to Photobucket forever. (Especially with the fact I've abandoned my account and moved on to other sites to share photos on.)
So yeah, still have them. Probably won't get rid of them or give them to my nieces and nephews since they have dogs who use them as chew toys.