There has been some discussion about the awards in the admin section already. There are going to be some changes this year. It might be better to wait for the official announcement and explanation of what those awards are even meant to be about, but I guess I already spilled some of the beans about it.
Hmm, just reading this a minute ago and coming up with a run-off the mill idea somebody's probably had before. I thought about classic LBT moments and I immediatley thought of Littlefoot hatching. Maybe the favourite newbie to the forum, which the hatching sort of symbolise.
Look at Littlefoot Fan's signature

He got the newby award of 2006 (the first year we did this) and it shows exactly the scene you are thinking of.
One of the things that is likely to change and which I am going to change for the older awards as well are some of the inscriptions. I will try to avoid "best" "friendliest" and other superlatives. "Friendly member 2008" is probably a less controversial inscription than "Friendliest member 2008". Another change we agreed on in the admin section is about the newby awards. In the last two years they were issued to members who had joined within the last year. This year however more than a third of the people who will be entitled to vote joined within the last year and many of you have done so much for the GOF that I guess many awards will this year go to the "newbys". Also the winner of the newby award of 2007 hasn't been heard of since last September. For all that the admins agreed that it might be better to create an award with the year a member joined. That award will be given to every member (without a vote) who joined in a particular year, once that year is so long passed that the members who joined then are definitely no temporary visitors only.
I think in one respect I was misunderstood. I am not looking for ideas for the look of the new awards. I have many ideas what they could look like, but I don't have the screenshots to create the awards. Does anyone of you have some screenshots saved on your PC(s)? I already "looted" many land before time pages for screenshots, but I thought that perhaps some of you have private collections as well which you would be willing to share for the creating of the awards?