The Gang of Five
The forum will have some maintenance done in the next couple of months. We have also made a decision concerning AI art in the art section.


Please see this post for more details.

The Pacific War... in models!

Pterano · 47 · 6542

Pterano

  • The Fabulous Fearsome Flyer
  • Member+
  • Ducky
  • *
    • Posts: 2937
    • View Profile
So this year will mark the 70th anniversary of the attack on Pearl Harbor, and as the Pacific War is one of my four main areas of historic concentration (the other three being the American Civil War, the French Revolutionary/Napoleonic Era, and the construction, competition and history of the great Transatlantic Liners), I've decided to do something a bit different for the 70th anniversary of the outbreak of this conflict.

Model collecting/building has always been a hobby of mine, and over the years I've amassed quite a large number of Union and Confederate ironclad models, as well as a good number of Japanese, American, British and Dutch warships from the Pacific War. My navies for the latter are nowhere near complete, but I constantly collect, and I figure by the time the 70th anniversary rolls around I will have definitely assembled the Japanese Striking Force or Kido Butai by that point. Now what would be REALLY impressive would be if I could also gather the American fleet at Pearl Harbor, but since there were at least three times the amount of ships docked there, I don't think my wallet will permit it at this point in time, however, fortunately, the battles after Pearl Harbor were smaller, fought at much closer ranges, and should be more manageable in terms of setting up (I've already done some for the Bougainville and later Solomons Campaigns).

I love setting up battles on tabletops in order to get a better understanding of the flow of them and what exactly occurred when. I'm more of a visual learner than anything, and I was wondering if anyone would be interested in perhaps following along with my chronological tracking of these combats? I figured that on the anniversary of each battle, I could take plenty of photos of the boards and models, and give detailed descriptions of what's going on when, as well as get analytical discussions going as well. I know there are a few history buffs here on the GoF, and I'd love to take in depth looks at these battles with any one of you, provided there's interest. I could set them all up, snap photos of the changing positions, and maybe even get like a blue matte or something to make my tabletops look a bit more like the ocean. :) We'll be moving house in October (THANKFULLY), and I'll have a LOT of room to play around with once we do, so I was thinking that yeah, this would be an interesting way of remembering this particular conflict for its 70th anniversary.

As said, I've begun assembling the Kido Butai, and I already have models for many of the battles in the Invasion of the Dutch East Indies and Solomon Islands, so it's really more of a question of gathering the carriers and some of the bigger ships. I could post some pictures too of the models that I use, and they're very detailed and should at least appeal to those going for historical accuracy.

So, would anyone here be interested in following this?

(runner up)
(runner up)
---------------------------------------------------

Poster of the Gang of Five's 400,000th post



Pterano

  • The Fabulous Fearsome Flyer
  • Member+
  • Ducky
  • *
    • Posts: 2937
    • View Profile
Alright, I'll enjoy going through the war with you. :) I should be able to take some pictures later on in the week. I'm buying about two models a week, and am expecting the Akagi and Hiei to arrive this week. I've got almost all the destroyers (I'm missing one I think) set up from the Kido Butai. Slow but sure process. :)

(runner up)
(runner up)
---------------------------------------------------

Poster of the Gang of Five's 400,000th post


Mirumoto_Kenjiro

  • Cera
  • *
    • Posts: 4137
    • View Profile
I play Axis & Allies, and this includes Naval Miniatures, so far I got formidable American, British, and Italian fleets (but by playing standards, not actual historic standards).

I'd love to see the pics when you take them.


Malte279

  • The Circle
  • The Gang of Five
  • *
    • Posts: 15608
    • View Profile
    • http://www.ineinemlandvorunsererzeit.de.vu
This sounds very interesting. Which scale are you working with? It is in the nature of 20th century naval battles (even the one that did not involve aircraft carriers) that they were fought over large distances.
When I was building models I was more focused on planes (including some of the Pacific theatre of WW2) than on ships, but I did have a couple (mostly very small 1:1200 scale ships) including the USS Enterpriese, USS Missouri, USS Arizona, the Yamato and a 1:72 scale model of the PT 117.
When you want to focus on the first months of the war (as seems to be your intention from what you wrote) you may want to include the USS Langley. For some reason the ship that was pretty much the first US carrier to be built as well as the first US carrier to be sunk receives very little attention. In the first months of the war you may also want to search for the difficult to find Dutch ships (e.g. the cruiser De Ruyter) that participated in the battle fo the Java Sea. For the earliest days of the war you may also be interested in the British Force Z sunk on December 10th 1941, the HMS Repulse and the HMS Prince of Wales (come to think of it I used to have a 1:1200 scale model of the later too) or the British ships attacked near Ceylon in April 1942 (including the carrier HMS Hermes).
What exactly are you planing for, setting up the fleets as such or setting up actual scale dioramas (which even in tiny 1:1200 scale will require a lot of space)?


Pterano

  • The Fabulous Fearsome Flyer
  • Member+
  • Ducky
  • *
    • Posts: 2937
    • View Profile
You'll be happy to know that I have every intention of focusing on the Dutch East Indies battles, Malte, including the Battle of the Java Sea, and I already have the De Ruyter, Java, Tromp (which was not present but did take part in the Battle of Badung Strait), and all Dutch destroyers that took part. :yes I need to get my hands on the Houston and the Perth, and but I do have the Exeter and the British destroyers as well as the American destroyers. I will also be focusing on the sinking of Force Z, as I have both the Prince of Wales and Repulse, and the Indian Ocean Raid when it comes up, and will be showing the attacks on the Hermes, Dorsetshire and Cornwall. :yes I also have USS Langley, and I hope to get a good discussion going about that particular one (as I consider her last mission HIGHLY controversial), so I'm glad you brought it up. :yes

I'll try and get some example pictures set up by tonight so you can see some examples of the models I have. I'm using 1/2400 I believe? They're pretty small, but they're HIGHLY detailed and are the most historically accurate I could get, plus they're all to scale, making setting up these combats very simple and realistic as well. I believe my Civil War ones are um... 1/600, but in order to get the absolute best detailed models I could find, I had to go with 1/2400 for the WWII ones.

As for dioramas, I MAY do that, if I have the cash and can get some stuff set up, but really I think any old greenish looking thing could fill in for an island or coast line :p

To explain a little better and answer your question, Malte, I'll try and break it down. What I plan to do is on the anniversary of a particular combat (the 70th naturally), I will set up a very large table (which won't be an issue once we move house in October as I'll have PLENTY of space, and I was thinking maybe I could even get two large tables and just put them a certain distance apart, for some of the longer range carrier battles), put down maybe a blue matte or blue painted carboard or something, set up any land features (if they exist in that combat), and then set up the opening positions for the combat for each side. I will then track the battle chronologically by moving the models to the various positions the real ships occupied as time went on, snap photos of it, and post them up here. By going in 5-15 minute increments, I think this will allow for some pretty detailed pictures in terms of positions of each ship and events occurring. :yes After the "battle" concludes, I'd definitely like to discuss with whoever was watching, and look at it from an analytic perspective. Hopefully I explained things a bit more clearly for you, and if you still have questions (or suggestions!), feel free to speak up. :)

What I think I'll try and do tonight is set up the formation used by both sides at the Battle of Empress Augusta Bay just to show what my models look like, and maybe get some close up shots as well of a few. If Akagi and Hiei arrive today, I'll be taking photos of them as well. :yes

(runner up)
(runner up)
---------------------------------------------------

Poster of the Gang of Five's 400,000th post


Pterano

  • The Fabulous Fearsome Flyer
  • Member+
  • Ducky
  • *
    • Posts: 2937
    • View Profile
OK, I'm probably gonna take pictures tomorrow, when I'm more awake/not exhausted. Today was long, grueling and wearisome at work, and it took me a few hours to assemble my new models (Akagi and Hiei), so yeah... I'll get to that tomorrow or this weekend. I ordered four new ones as I got a discount with this purchase, and now I have the Kaga, Kirishima, Soryu and Tone on the way. :) Probably be here next week.

But yeah, I'll try to set up the Empress Augusta Bay formations for the photo shoot as an example over the next few days. :)

(runner up)
(runner up)
---------------------------------------------------

Poster of the Gang of Five's 400,000th post


Pterano

  • The Fabulous Fearsome Flyer
  • Member+
  • Ducky
  • *
    • Posts: 2937
    • View Profile
And as promised, here are some pictures of my models. In particular, these are pictures of the Kido Butai, and the formation they used as they sailed out to throw their attack against Pearl Harbor. You may notice these are not painted. Will I be painting them? Maybe... but I have big hands that aren't always steady so... :p


Here we see the formation used by the Kido Butai. A light cruiser (Abukuma) out in front, a destroyer screen steaming abreast behind it, followed by two heavy cruisers, and the carriers, steaming in three columns abreast (or two parallel) with the battleships Hiei and Kirishima bringing up the rear. Two destroyers are on the left flank. Those were the Midway Destruction Unit, or two Fubuki class destroyers meant to shell Midway Island.


The same formation from the rear.


Looking directly behind the formation.


The battleship Hiei with Kirishima (Gunichi Mikawa's flagship) in the background. The stern of Shokaku is also visible.


Carrier Soryu with Akagi in the background.


Carrier Kaga


Carrier Akagi, flagship of the Kido Butai.


Battleship Kirishima, flagship of Gunichi Mikawa.


Carrier Hiryu with Kaga in the background.


Carrier Shokaku


(runner up)
(runner up)
---------------------------------------------------

Poster of the Gang of Five's 400,000th post


Pterano

  • The Fabulous Fearsome Flyer
  • Member+
  • Ducky
  • *
    • Posts: 2937
    • View Profile
And a few more.


Carrier Zuikaku with Shokaku in the background. Bow of Kirishima is also visible.


The destroyer screen up front. Eight Kagero class and two Asashio class. Cruiser Chikuma visible in the background, as is bow of the Tone. Light cruiser Abukuma leads the formation.


Battleship Hiei, taken before I set up this formation.


Battleship Kirishima.

(runner up)
(runner up)
---------------------------------------------------

Poster of the Gang of Five's 400,000th post


vonboy

  • Chomper: "Threehorns are better at everything, including rumpsteaks"
  • Member+
  • Ducky
  • *
    • Posts: 2753
    • View Profile
I remember a couple of months back, when you showed me some pictures of this while you were still piecing together models, and waiting for more of them to come in the mail.

I'm still astounded by how detailed these models are for only being a couple inches in length.

What's your plan for this now?
Come check out my new Youtube gaming channel, Game Biter!
---------------------
Littlefoot: "Look, Chomper. You're uncle is dead, and it's just right for your friends to be there for you. You'd be there if someone we know died, right?"

Chomper: "Well, sure I would!"

Come give my LBT TV Series fanfiction, PAST-O-RAMA, a read!
---------------------
(Runner-Up)


Pterano

  • The Fabulous Fearsome Flyer
  • Member+
  • Ducky
  • *
    • Posts: 2937
    • View Profile
Yeah heheh, I remember those discussions. Was waiting on some of these to arrive. :)

Yeah I know. I really love GHQ. They make sure to get really historically accurate detail out of their models, which is one they're one of the primary vendors I go to for this hobby. :yes

Well the plan is to reenact the battles of the Pacific War on their anniversaries through photos. The 70th anniversary of Pearl Harbor is coming up on December 7th, and my plan is basically to set up formations for each battle beforehand, snap photos of it, post 'em here, and then move the models around as the battle progresses, and post more photos. Once the battle is over (or as it's going on), I hope to generate some good discussions on the tactics and happenings of each one. :)

(runner up)
(runner up)
---------------------------------------------------

Poster of the Gang of Five's 400,000th post


Pterano

  • The Fabulous Fearsome Flyer
  • Member+
  • Ducky
  • *
    • Posts: 2937
    • View Profile
Today is the 70th anniversary of the Japanese Cabinet ratifying Prime Minister Tojo's decision to go to war on December 8th with the United States, the Netherlands, and Great Britain.

The Pearl Harbor Striking Force is already at sea, having sailed in secret from Tankan Bay in the Kurile Islands on November 26th (refer to the above pictures). Their orders are to continue on their northerly course and if detected, are to turn back and abort their mission, unless they're discovered on the 6th, in which case they'll sink the discovering ship, and continue at full speed to their launching point. Fortunately for them (and unfortunately for the Americans), only one ship is encountered on their passage, and it happens to be Japanese.

Admiral Husband Kimmel, commander of the United States Pacific Fleet, has received intelligence that some of the carrier radio chatter is no longer present in Tokyo Bay, but he disregards it as insignificant, not imagining that they are in fact on their way to strike at his anchorage, as attacks on the Philippines and Guam are much more likely in his mind.

The Striking Force has been battering its way through very rough seas and thick fog, with lookouts being washed overboard in the harsh conditions. But the northerly route was chosen to avoid detection, and it ends up working perfectly in terms of achieving surprise. The Striking Force consists of:

Light cruiser Abukuma (leading the destroyers).

Destroyers: Urakaze, Isokaze, Tanikaze, Hamakaze, Kagero, Shiranuhi, Arare, Kasumi, Sazanami, and Ushio. The destroyers are steaming in line abreast ahead of the main body, to act as a screen and sink any foreign vessel encountered to prevent them raising an alarm. The last two are steaming on the left flank, and will serve as a bombarding force that will attack Midway Island.

Heavy cruisers: Tone, Chikuma. The heavy cruisers are serving as the vanguard of the carriers, and will launch float planes before the Pear Harbor strike to reconnoiter the harbor beforehand.

Carriers: Akagi (Red Castle, flagship of Admiral Chuichi Nagumo), Kaga (Increased Joy), Soryu (Blue Dragon), Hiryu (Flying Dragon), Shokaku (Flying Crane), Zuikaku (Fortunate Crane). The carriers will be delivering the strike. 408 aircraft are slated to be used, with 360 in two attack waves and 48 for combat air patrol or CAP.

Battleships: Kirishima, Hiei. The battleships are bringing up the rear, and acting as the heavy escorts in case significant trouble comes their way, but the Japanese encounter nothing on the way out.

In addition to this, Force Z, a powerful force consisting of the battleship HMS Prince of Wales, battlecruiser Repulse, and destroyers Electra, Express, Encounter, and Jupiter, are only a day away from Singapore, after having rendezvoused in the Indian Ocean. They are part of the British battle plan to deter Japanese aggression in the Dutch East Indies/Malay Peninsula area. It is under the command of Admiral Tom Phillips, in the Prince of Wales. Unlike the Americans, Dutch, and Australians, who by and large are focusing on defending the Dutch East Indies from Surabaya, the British are focusing at Singapore, as they believe it to be impregnable, with the rest of the allies disagreeing on that. No formal battle plan has been adopted by the joint allied command in the southwest Pacific, and the allied command is fractious with no solid idea on how they're going to focus on defending their territories, only that they're going to work together to curb Japanese aggression from spreading further south.

(runner up)
(runner up)
---------------------------------------------------

Poster of the Gang of Five's 400,000th post


jansenov

  • Member+
  • Ducky
  • *
    • Posts: 2665
    • View Profile
Force Z had such a tragic ending. Admiral Phillips wasn't sufficiently informed about Japanese capabilities, he gambled and he lost. Allied intelligence utterly failed in the Malayan Campaign, which lead to the fall of Singapore.


Pterano

  • The Fabulous Fearsome Flyer
  • Member+
  • Ducky
  • *
    • Posts: 2937
    • View Profile
Indeed, Hrvoje. :yes You know your stuff on this subject. :DD I'll be discussing that in the coming week. Not just the loss of Force Z, but I'll be talking about the loss of Malaya as well, and the factors that led to it. Phillips was a capable sea officer, but you're right. Allied intelligence was very bad, and they had not yet come up with an effective battle strategy when the Japanese blitzed them. The British wanted to focus on Singapore, and the Americans, Dutch, and Australians wanted to focus on defending the "Malay Barrier", or line formed by the Dutch East Indies using Surabaya.

(runner up)
(runner up)
---------------------------------------------------

Poster of the Gang of Five's 400,000th post


Mirumoto_Kenjiro

  • Cera
  • *
    • Posts: 4137
    • View Profile
Are those models in the pictures in pewter?  It looks almost metal, and it looks around the same sizes as the plastic Axis&Allies miniatures I collect.

Anyway, I like the collection you got.


Pterano

  • The Fabulous Fearsome Flyer
  • Member+
  • Ducky
  • *
    • Posts: 2937
    • View Profile
Those are pewter models, yes. :yes And thanks! :DD

So today, December 2nd, Admiral Isoroku Yamamoto, commander of the Imperial Japanese Navy, broadcasts to the Striking Force "Niitaka yama nobore", or "Climb Mt. Niitaka", which is the signal for the attack to commence. The Striking Force responds by darkening ship and going to Condition 2, or one step below full battle readiness as they continue on their sluggish way across the North Pacific. They are traveling at a slow 13 knots in order to accommodate the oil tankers following them, but their scheduled refueling date is tomorrow, and the tankers will be left behind once it's completed.

Also today, Force Z (called Force G at the time) arrives at Singapore, and joins with the rest of the British forces present, which mostly consist of cruisers and destroyers, many of them undergoing various states of repair. Admiral Phillips docks his force, which is now re-designated Force Z, but time is running out. There is now less than a week to the Japanese invasion, and they will strike sooner than any of the Allied commanders anticipate.

Force Z is supposed to be supplemented by the carrier Indomitable, but she ran aground during her maiden voyage in the Caribbean, and suffered damage. The only other British carrier in the vicinity is the Hermes, but her slow speed rules her out as a factor to accompany Force Z.

(runner up)
(runner up)
---------------------------------------------------

Poster of the Gang of Five's 400,000th post


Pterano

  • The Fabulous Fearsome Flyer
  • Member+
  • Ducky
  • *
    • Posts: 2937
    • View Profile
Today, December 3rd, is the refueling date for the Pearl Harbor Strike Force. The weather moderates enough for a successful refueling at sea from the tankers, and once it's completed, the Strike Force cuts loose from the supply train and increases speed from 13 to 26 knots. They have enough fuel now to go almost all out, and in order to reach the launch point on schedule, a much higher speed is now maintained.

(runner up)
(runner up)
---------------------------------------------------

Poster of the Gang of Five's 400,000th post


Pterano

  • The Fabulous Fearsome Flyer
  • Member+
  • Ducky
  • *
    • Posts: 2937
    • View Profile
Today, President of the United States Franklin Roosevelt authorizes something called the Manhattan Engineering District, which will later become the Manhattan Project, or the development of the Atomic Bomb.

Also today, the Pearl Harbor Striking Force receives the most up to date intelligence it can on the composition of the US Pacific Fleet at Pearl. Agents working for Japan stationed on Oahu transmit the info to Tokyo via the consulate, and Tokyo radios it to the Strike Force. Seven battleships, seven cruisers... but no carriers. Admiral Nagumo is disappointed at this. The carriers were the main goal of the attack, and with them gone, the strategic value of the raid shifts a little. The USS Saratoga is in for a refit on the west coast. The USS Enterprise and USS Lexington are both at sea, delivering planes to Wake Island and Midway Island respectively.

However, as the next day, the 7th, is a Sunday, most of the Pacific Fleet will be in harbor. The fleet's regular schedule usually had them training at sea during the week, and returning to Pearl for the weekend. As the majority of the fleet will still be present, Nagumo continues on his course as before, intending to launch the raid at first light tomorrow. Remarkably, the radio traffic he picks up from Pearl is encouraging, as it shows no signs of alert, and the patrols flown out of Pearl are directed primarily to the southwest, thus, it seems his launch point, to the north of Hawaii, will be safe from detection. With all his intelligence pointing to his surprise remaining strong, Nagumo makes the final decision to attack Pearl Harbor tonight.

(runner up)
(runner up)
---------------------------------------------------

Poster of the Gang of Five's 400,000th post


The Chronicler

  • Bionicle fan of GoF
  • Member+
  • Cera
  • *
    • Posts: 5556
    • View Profile
I guess this is a good enough topic for me to mention this. If anyone is interested, there will be a two-hour program on the History Channel tomorrow at 8:00 p.m. that's basically about how America and President Roosevelt reacted to the attack on Pearl Harbor within the first 24 hours.

"I have a right to collect anything I want. It's just junk anyway."
- Berix

My first fanfiction: Quest for the Energy Stones
My unfinished and canceled second fanfiction: Quest for the Mask of Life
My currently ongoing fanfiction series: LEGO Equestria Girls



f-22 "raptor" ace

  • Member+
  • Littlefoot
  • *
    • Posts: 6830
    • View Profile
Quote from: The Chronicler,Dec 6 2011 on  10:12 PM
I guess this is a good enough topic for me to mention this. If anyone is interested, there will be a two-hour program on the History Channel tomorrow at 8:00 p.m. that's basically about how America and President Roosevelt reacted to the attack on Pearl Harbor within the first 24 hours.
I'll be watching it.